A new attempt to reform pro cycling has been launched with the Collective Cycling Group (CCG) taking over from the One Cycling Project. Already one big difference is that CCG has been launched while One Cyclingnever got to the announcement stage. It’s a new project and more will be unveiled next month but there’s now a website and some things to chew over.
As launches go it’s curt and pending a presentation next month. The aborted One Cycling venture set up a British-registered company with Visma-LAB team boss Richard Plugge as sole director. Now the same legal entity has been reprised and given a name change – “Two Pro Cycling” quipped the Cycling Podcast – and earlier this year a declaration showed that Plugge resigned and a new person came in named Oliver Ciesla, a former motorsport executive.
Now there’s a website at collectivecyclinggroup.com which marks the start of communication. It’s so tentative it doesn’t list the member teams or others backing the Collective Cycling Group (CCG). The website says 24 teams but apparently there are 26, according to reporter Chris Marshall-Bell who doing a good job on this brief. Which teams, some of this includes outfits with men’s and women’s teams but it’s easier to list the ones not on board like UAE, Red Bull and Ineos although Marshall-Bell says the latter two are still in talks. One big backer is Ivan Glasenberg, the South African mining and commodities billionaire, who is behind the Pinarello-Q36.5 team, something known rather than stated.
There’s going to be a launch proper in Benidorm next month alongside the UCI’s annual gala gathering where the governing body will also give an update on its proposed reforms. Ahead of this some things from the website give us a few clues. We’ve got the bombast of a Velon press release, the attributed quote to Ciesla of “this broad and inclusive initiative by so many teams represents a significant milestone in the long and proud history of the sport” is a bold claim given all we’ve got is some teams coming together again to form another group. Now it’s not just a committee or a WhatsApp group, there’s legal agreements, shareholder subscriptions and more: but nothing in the sport has changed. For a quiz when was the Velon group founded? Which year did the Gifted Group try a breakaway project? When did the Hammer Series start? If you can’t remember don’t worry, the 2010s will do as an answer, it’s just to suggest it may be a milestone but it’ll take delivery before historians concur.
Will it be different this time?
The CCG website’s tone sounds different in places, rather than earlier plans to privatise the sport and establish closed systems, now “CCG works within the sport’s framework, alongside its governing bodies, organisers and riders”. This sounds wiser given reform is easier than revolution. But it’s not necessarily new, the Hammer Series races were put on the pro calendar, ie working with the UCI.
But… the CCG website says “very major sport relies on three revenue streams. Cycling stands on one. Ticketing, broadcast and sponsorship hold up football, motorsport and the major global sports leagues. While races must stay free to attend, teams should have the collective weight to negotiate broadcasting deals fairly”. This is meaty as CCG want to be in the room for TV broadcast deals. This zombie argument lives on – memorably the New York Times last summer complete with wrong numbers – and you can find some logical inoculation in last summer’s Revenue Sharing Re-Revisited post. To save you a click even using wildly generous numbers gets €5 million per team, as in nice but not making a difference to teams that run on north of €30 million a year average where losing a title sponsorship is still going to be fatal unless there’s a sugardaddy to cover things. But that €5 million per team? Nevermind a share of TV rights, it comes from donating all of ASO’s profits to the teams which is rather unlikely.
Four problems
CCG identifies four problems:
- First is that “funding leans almost entirely on sponsors. When a backer leaves, a team can vanish, and with it, riders’ careers” which is true but note we see the likes of Visma-LAB, Jayco and others are still here because they have wealthy owners who can backfill missing sponsorship. Not always of course, see Arkéa, Qhubeka or CCC but we can all see the point. The harder part is structuring the sport such that a team can continue in the event of the loss of a title sponsor, it would mean making sponsorship revenue as a top-up rather than the fundamental source of income.
- Second is that “with budgets increasing and the need to invest in safety, fan engagement, and innovation, that unique reliance on sponsors is not sustainable” and it’s true that the sport is in danger of pricing itself too high. To a large extent this is down to the teams more than the UCI or organisers of course but there is scope here for some self-imposed regulation where teams agree to budget caps and other regulation which presumably is set by the UCI.
- Third is that “cycling now competes with streaming and near-infinite entertainment. The experience that held attention five years ago no longer does” and this rings true given the distractions available. But this has always been the case. You could watch Eddy Merckx or read about Alfredo Binda but also read or twiddle your thumbs, it’s human nature to have competing calls on time and attention. Can cycling outdo Tiktok and short form video? Probably not but actually viewing figures are decent in an era of audience fragmentation, the ratings are alright. Plus it’s all real and organic, genuine sport rather than avatars chasing each other around a virtual world. Road cycling can’t compete in a world of 36 second videos but its unique selling point of filling hours of airtime with sport and scenery is a selling point too, just in a different way.
- Fourth is that “organised race by race, the sport has never had a professionally run platform to represent teams, to invest jointly and support the growth of the sport”. This is true, it’s why if you want race results and rankings you probably use firstcycling or procyclingstats more than the UCI. That is more factual of course but indicative of how entrepreneurs have filled the gap. What CCG seems to want is a joint platform for the teams to market themselves and probably promote some races among themselves, much like the Hammer Series tried. Beyond this are topics like
Combined these points reinforce the idea of a project firmly based around the interests of its member teams, it’s not there to support amateur races, to save endangered events or entertain wider causes like encouraging more people to ride bikes, it’s the financial predicament of the teams that is at stake first. CCG of course is bound to say that an improved sport is good for teams and vice versa.
Finally one small thing is that this is the rebirth of the One Cycling entity while Velon remains a separate company, also British-registered. It’s a small quirk that both exist, but Velon has seen plenty of resignations of team managers so looks to shrivelled.
Conclusion
It’s the teams again. The same people who thought partnering the Saudi Public Investment Fund was a grand idea now bring us the CCG. Yes, a snarky point but hard to resist and it’d be a good question to put to CCG. A more serious point is that Ivan Glasenberg wasn’t there before. He has thrived as a deal maker to put it mildly and if he, and some of his money is involved, then it’s worth studying seriously although as we’ve seen with other billionaires – Jim Ratcliffe comes to mind – what made them successful one domain doesn’t equate to others.
Multiple past attempts have failed, and for similar reasons: there’s not much money to share and teams struggle to convince that they deserve protected funding, especially when they’re backed by large corporates, sovereign states and billionaires. Given the way this one sounds similar, it’s easy to be cynical. However lessons are being learned, the tone from CCG looks like reform from within rather than confrontation and that might prove more suitable; although the Velon group hasn’t got very far with this. Plus there’s a sense that at some point a tussle with the UCI could emerge.
Changing the business model is a big ask. Smaller things can be achieved today. There are things to do, if teams feel they’re pricing themselves out of the sport then some collective action to limit budget inflation can be implemented, a cohort of teams agreeing to this can be a major impetus but a majority is necessary but not sufficient, there’s a lot of detail to iron out but given the group seems well-funded, they can set to work on this. As said before here, everyone likes the idea of “reform” but detail them and you quickly find outcomes that create winners and losers; for example to to cap team budgets is to put a brake on rider pay and so on.